An Election and Three Pedicures
For trans families, change comes faster, and slower. Sometimes in color.
This week a friend sent a video of her horse being re-shod. It was shocking. A lot gets into a hoof that has to come out.
The farrier started by hacking out parts of barn floor compressed into the hoof—so many, heavy clods of earth and dust. Then he dug out an inch thickness, maybe more, of translucent stuff that looked like fingernail keratin, except thick as a windshield. At this point the farrier was carving so deeply he might have been rough-sculpting a gargoyle. Next he used a different, bigger tool—imagine a nail clipper for a tractor trailer—that bit off the hoof-edge, all around it. Finally came the shoeing: banging, pounding, singeing, marking, scraping, sanding, smoothing.
The horse stood there the whole time. How could it not hurt? Putting a hoof right is a carpentry job.
Agog
Last Tuesday’s midterm election was as shocking as the farrier reel. Watching the returns, it felt like tons of debris was being dug out old hooves and flung into buckets. It felt like a persistent fungus living on the body of all of us was starting to be scraped and peeled off and cauterized.
The people in my circles who love someone trans—along with millions of other people in hundreds of other communities whose civil rights have been stolen slowly and quickly in Trump time—have had the worst two years of their (our) lives. A pervasive fear runs under our days and nights. Plenty of trans families and people who could leave the country, left.
I didn’t have much emotion invested in the midterms, because if things got worse, they were already so bad. It seemed like the election might go well, but, I felt, we were going to be OK no matter what. If there was violence at the polls, a stolen election, or every democrat lost, we would keep on fighting and living our defiant lives.
It felt like a persistent fungus living on the body of all of us was starting to be scraped and peeled off and cauterized.
Then on election night, astonishments started to happen. And kept happening. Agog reporters tried to find words to analyze the latest impossible, unprecedented flipping of a legislative seat. There were jokes during the broadcast—jokes. It felt nice to laugh again, like it had been 10,000 years. “I just had a reaction from Trump handed to me [on a piece of paper],” Rachel Maddow said, “and I lost it. And it doesn’t matter. I don’t have to care!”

Finally what the people said drowned out what Trump said, whatever that was.
I meant to just glance at the returns before bed. I wound up watching all night, not blinking. My eyeballs burned through Texas, Georgia, Alabama, Maine, and into the morning. As I type these words, it looks like Alaska is about to deliver an additional new senator to the Democrats.
The yellow, the green
A bit over a decade ago, my child went to kindergarten one morning in overalls, sandals, and a pedicure. We had painted each other’s toenails the night before after hanging out in the garden. Daffodils were up: their cold yellow was the inspiration for every other of our toes being yellow. The green on our alternating toes was the color of new stems.
In the back of my head I wondered if the kids at school would say anything. My child went by “him” then and was known as a boy. But I was fairly sure the feet would be a nonstarter. This was kindergarten forgodsake, where everyone gets covered with paint every day. Well, I was wrong, My kid got mocked off the playground.
I was angry not at the children, but their parents, the sole source (I thought) of mindless stereotypes. The idea that boys don’t like bright color and enjoy putting it on their bodies. In kindergarten.
I stuck my rage on those parents and there it stayed, festering.
Defection
My rage festered through Izzy’s early childhood and into middle school, where a sex ed teacher bisected her class by “birth-given gender,” as though gender were a present tied with a bow and not a random assignment with unspoken rules you would be punished for breaking. That teacher didn’t bother to imagine what nonbinary kids might feel learning about sex in a room with cis boys and girls.
In 9th grade, a history teacher announced “tomorrow we’re going to divide into boys and girls” for some discussion or other. What’s up with that bullshit, I said when Izzy told me about the assignment, and what should I do about it? “It’s not a big deal,” Izzy insisted, looking worried, like I might do a performative intervention with puppets. “Don’t do anything.” (She had just come out as trans.)
And so I, who promised myself never to sit on my hands, sat on my hands, because it was time. And, astonishingly to me, the kids handled it themselves. Girls defected into the boys group, fucking up the lesson plan, making good trouble. And the teacher called in sick that day.
Coward.
The red, the blue
My kid’s painted nails at age 6 didn’t “make her trans.” Gender comes from inside a person and is just one part of us, like hair color. Not a big deal or a national crisis. One reason Dems swept the midterms was most people agree and voted for candidates that expressed full-throated support for trans and queer people. “the only minority destroying this country is the billionaires,” James Talarico pointed out.
Yes, a few blue candidates sprinkled anti-trans ads into their campaigns. Some anti-trans ballot measures passed. Everything isn’t rainbows; trans youth healthcare wasn’t restored overnight. There is plenty of change to fight for long-term.
But we have better people to fight now than we did on Nov. 2. That’s what we voted for: the candidates we’d rather fight with, who potentially will listen to us. We will make them listen.
Delight
A few weeks before the election, a friend’s kid, Wyatt, went to preschool with purple toenails and fingernails. The dad (a cis dad) was the one who painted them. My mom friend lowkey dreaded what kids at school might say, what the teacher might say. What she would have to deal with when Wyatt got home.
Instead of mocking him, three boys went home that day planning to paint their nails like Wyatt’s. Instead of being angry or dismissive, other parents called my friend to express delight. One mom texted her from a trip to the manicure aisle at Target with her son. My friend was astonished. I was too. People are more accepting than they were a decade ago. And way more than they were when we were kids.
— N.R.
Noa Rabinow is a health care worker, an editor at Gender Defiant, and mom to a trans teen.
Gender Defiant will always be free to read. consider a paid subscription to support our work: